Crimes against humanity, barbarism, ethnic cleansing, urban genocide—all of that is fine, but using the word “Genoc…” to describe the events in Gaza is simply unacceptable. It’s not kosher and inevitably invites accusations of anti-Semitism, because after the Holocaust, that term is reserved—a sort of protected trademark—for the massacre of Jews at Auschwitz and elsewhere by the Nazis.
It doesn’t matter that this term is deemed appropriate by Israeli medical and scientific organizations, Holocaust survivors and their children, human rights organizations, B’Tselem, Israeli NGOs, and groups around the world: it’s the truth on one side of the Mediterranean, but not on the other. The term is simply banned and punishable in France and the United Kingdom by prosecution and imprisonment. No one disputes the indiscriminate and despicable terrorism perpetrated by Hamas on October 7 (which, incidentally, the ICJ has deemed potentially genocidal), but nothing justifies the scale of destruction and crimes committed by the State of Israel since then—including the destruction of virtually everything that enables a population to live: hospitals; clinical services, universities, and schools—the massacre of children and journalists—in short, anything that moves. The intent is beyond doubt, and what’s most ironic—if one were to take things lightly for a second—is that Israeli political leaders make no secret of it and proclaim to anyone willing to listen—especially in Hebrew—that everyone must be killed, including babies—and to make this area uninhabitable in order to rid it once and for all of its inhabitants so that it can be populated by Jews already ready to invade it and bring divine blessing there.
The situation is all the more unbearable because it was instigated by a prime minister who secured funding for Hamas—notably from Qatar—in order to weaken the Palestinian Authority with the aim of preventing any two-state solution. Who benefits from this crime? Bibi, of course, who facilitated this massacre by reducing border controls in Gaza at the crucial moment—and even scaling back guard towers on that fateful morning. The establishment of an independent commission—which he opposed with all his might—will finally reveal the extent of this man’s bad faith; he is currently being prosecuted by the International Court of Justice for war crimes and suspected genocide.
Strictly adhering to his Hippocratic Oath, Dr. Pitti has long worked tirelessly to provide medical aid and bring an end to the massacres in Gaza. Haunted, like many foreign doctors, reporters, and various public figures who have been there and witnessed the extent of the abominable terror and famine, he has spoken out in the media about the urgent needs of the people of Gaza, using the forbidden word “Geno..de.” https://www.radiofrance.fr/ici/podcasts/l-invite-de-la-redaction-de-ici-lorraine-7232235
As a result, he is being sued for anti-Semitism by the Association of Israeli Doctors in France before the Disciplinary Court of First Instance of the Grand Est Regional Council of the Order of Physicians: https://france3-regions.franceinfo.fr/grand-est/moselle/metz/un-medecin-devant-la-chambre-disciplinaire-du-conseil-regional-de-l-ordre-apres-avoir-qualifie-la-situation-a-gaza-de-genocide-3445506.html. The argument is bizarre, as Jouvet would say: “Tragedies unfold elsewhere, and the only tragedy for which we use this vocabulary is the one unfolding in Gaza.” Describing what is happening in Gaza in this way will “harm the Jews of France.” Dr. Pitti responds, “Chaos reigned inside the hospital. It was impossible to maintain hygiene; there were no antibiotics, no oxygen, no surgical equipment. It was like 1914–1918, with systematic amputations”. A chilling description to which he adds: “We were forced to let patients with head trauma and children with burns covering more than 30% of their bodies die. Yet there were ships. But the Israelis wouldn’t let us use them. Journalists weren’t there to expose all of this. Should I keep quiet?” he asks the audience. ARCOM—whose swiftness is not exactly its strong suit, given the torrents of mudslinging and racism spewed by certain media outlets with little or no reaction—responded quickly, emphasizing “the importance of exercising, in the future, greater vigilance regarding the moderation required when broadcasting debates on such sensitive topics.” In short, as always, a massacre in Sudan or Thailand can be labeled genocide, but not in Israel—because it is committed by Jews (Israelis) concerning Israel and thus has repercussions for all Jews worldwide. This takeover of Judaism by a government that illegally occupies Gaza as well as the West Bank, parts of southern Lebanon, and Syria—and which threatens all its neighbors with one of the world’s most powerful armies—is finally beginning to make Western governments realize the mistake of supporting it.
We must return to the fundamentals: people like Dr. Pitti deserve our admiration and support because he is preserving what little conscience we have left. Our leaders would do well to remember this and put an end to this absurd aid to a country that has become unfit for association.
Photo : Raphaël Pitti, on November 6, 2026, before the first-instance disciplinary chamber of the Grand Est Regional Council of the French Order of Physicians. • © Coline Lexpert – France Télévisions




