The Development of the Visual System: Genes and Activity Follow One Another in Utero!

A few decades ago, Hubel and Wiesel described in detail how the visual system functions by recording neuronal responses to visual stimuli during early stages of maturation. They showed, for example, that neurons stimulated only with specific signals—such as horizontal bars—would subsequently respond only to those bars. These properties become irreversible after a critical period. Their Nobel Prize in Medicine was awarded for their elucidation of how vision works and its plasticity. This description came a few years after another giant of neuroscience—Vernon Mountcastle—had discovered the columnar organization of the sensorimotor cortex, paving the way for understanding how our cortex and sensory systems function. This topological organization has proven to be valid for all our senses, giving the impression of a somewhat map-like system. 

A few weeks ago, Professor Carla Shatz of Harvard received the Grand Prize from the French Academy of Sciences after having been awarded the prestigious European Kavli Prize for Brain Research for her work on the maturation of the visual system. Such is the nature of science: a somewhat rigid mapping is followed by brain maturation with its unique plasticity. Brain development becomes the Gordian knot of understanding the brain. To understand how the brain functions, we must determine how it develops—not just its connections and components—much like a TV, where simply listing its components is not enough to reconstruct it.

Carla Shatz’s research shows that “the neurons in the eye are not initially connected to the neurons in the brain. They must therefore extend long projections [axons] toward the brain, then find the right place to establish connections, or ‘synapses.’ This process begins very early, long before the eye can see and convert light information into a neural signal.” In fact, this wiring occurs early during brain development, guided by genetic instructions: the extensions of retinal neurons receive precise molecular instructions to travel toward the back of the brain, branch off toward the other hemisphere when necessary, and organize this topological mapping. But it is important to note that “the brain is already plastic in utero, well before birth—this is crucial.” This mapping must first be validated; much like building a road, the chosen path must be tested against the realities of the terrain for validation. In her research, Professor Shatz identifies a number of molecular signals that initiate and direct these connections, but she also emphasizes the importance of brain activity in this process. It has been known for several years that the gene-mediated automatic mapping phase occurs during the first part of brain development, but that subsequently—particularly during the second and third trimesters of gestation—there is a fine-tuning of these connections through a long list of parameters, including neuronal activity.

In this context, I believe it is useful to recall our own work in this field, which established a framework for the development of the visual system based on neural activity from rodents to premature infants. We had shown that rodents—which are blind at birth—respond to visual stimulation with a “retinal wave,” a long-duration electrical response incompatible with vision. These waves are present in all animal species, including, in fact, premature infants, and have therefore been preserved throughout evolution, attesting to their importance. Although they do not encode visual information, they are crucial for the development of the visual system; if they are blocked, the system develops improperly because the connections are not validated. In rodents, the duration of the visual response gradually decreases until it reaches a value compatible with vision when the newborn mouse opens its eyes and begins to see. In premature infants, this prolonged response also disappears when the time is right. Interestingly, if the optic tract is electrically stimulated in rodents, the appropriate brief response is evoked at an early stage, indicating that the retina is the limiting immature factor and not the subsequent stages. Formed during the first trimester of gestation, the retina remains immature for a long time and matures gradually, allowing for initially poor vision at birth that develops during a brief adaptation period. Such is the nature of science: new concepts emerge. A well-established, somewhat automated mapping process—which only makes sense after a period of adaptation that validates this map—is succeeded by a development-based approach, in line with a current general trend of focusing our efforts on the construction of the brain and its countless challenges. Genes and the environment work together to establish the blueprint, then test and validate it. Here, as elsewhere, there is a close interaction between hardware and software; both are necessary to build a system that is functional, efficient, and personalized, taking lived experience into account. This construction is by no means an automated process but rather a series of quality checks and critical periods during which these elements are validated or invalidated based on the information obtained throughout the process. This shift toward brain development also has therapeutic aspects, as many brain disorders arise during this process and are associated with therapies aimed at addressing the changes in maturation that have occurred.

Colonnese MT, Kaminska A, Minlebaev M, Milh M, Bloem B, Lescure S, Moriette G, Chiron C, Ben-Ari Y, Khazipov R. A conserved switch in sensory processing prepares developing neocortex for vision. Neuron. 2010 Aug 12;67(3):480-98
Hanganu IL, Ben-Ari Y, Khazipov R. Retinal waves trigger spindle bursts in the neonatal rat visual cortex. J Neurosci. 2006 Jun 21;26(25):6728-36. 

Photo: Pexels – MART PRODUCTION

Découvrez tous les sites de Yehezkel Ben-Ari/Discover all Yehezkel Ben-Ari websites

Le Blog de Ben-Ari
B&A Biomedical
B&A Oncomedical
Neurochlore
Portail Ben-Ari